388
Экология
«Молодой учёный» . № 8 (88) . Апрель, 2015 г.
Nuclear energy: is it good or bad for the environment?
Кондранова Анастасия Михайловна, магистрант;
Куимова Марина Валерьевна, кандидат педагогических наук, доцент
Национальный исследовательский Томский политехнический университет
Kondranova Anastasiya Mikhailovna, student
Kuimova Marina Valeryevna, PhD in Methods of TFL
National research Tomsk polytechnic university
I’ve always been concerned about global warming.
It seemed to me like working in nuclear power was a logical way
to do something to help the environment
Leslie Dewan
C
urrently the percentage of nuclear energy production is
rather low in the world, but it is likely to go up in the
years to come. Russia is one of the countries that produces
electricity from nuclear energy. Advanced, innovative nu-
clear technologies and engineering constructions are used
for the production of nuclear fuel. However, the production
of nuclear energy is not the main source of energy due to a
number of drawbacks:
− high cost of the construction of nuclear power plants
and insurance of safety and reliability;
− nuclear waste (people and the environment must be
protected from the radioactive waste. It is to be isolated and
dealt with safety);
− high cost of storage and disposal of the radioactive
waste (nuclear waste decays slowly and is of serious hazard
for thousands of years);
− risks of waste leaks and transportation mishaps;
− release of radioactive gases to the atmosphere;
− danger of accidents (terror attacks, volcanic eruption,
earthquakes, tsunami, flooding, tornados, etc.) [5, 9, 10].
Nuclear accidents in Chernobyl and Fukushima caused
dramatic after-effects due to the release of radioactive mate-
rials. It takes years to restore the environment and people’s
health [1]. It is noteworthy that nuclear wastes are hazardous
for many years and present a huge threat to our future gen-
erations. Moreover, nuclear energy facilities may be trans-
ferred from civil to military aims to contribute to the prolifer-
ation of weapons. Nuclear power plants must be well secured
as not to become the target of terrorist organizations [7]. To
avoid and minimize all possible dangers, the production and
management of nuclear energy must be a high and achiev-
able priority in the countries with nuclear power plants.
However, there are sound offsetting justifications for the
production of nuclear energy and operation of nuclear power
plants:
− does not require a large area for the construction and
work;
− does not depend on weather, like solar or wind, or hy-
droelectric plants;
− produces a million times more energy in comparison
with wind or hydro turbines;
− does not produce carbon dioxide;
− does not emit gases and smoke particles;
− produces a relatively small volume of waste, although
it is highly radioactive [6, 7, 8].
These benefits give some researcher the presumption to
claim that nuclear energy is the way to stop global warming
as they do not emit green house gases [2, 3, 4].
There is no unique solution to the problem of nuclear en-
ergy. Nuclear power plants produce electricity without green-
house gas emissions which gives it environmental advan-
tages over fossil fuels. At the same time, there are numerous
moral, ethical and spiritual reasons against nuclear energy,
as accidents may lead to catastrophic consequences both to
peoples’ lives and to the environment. Moreover, there are
challenging issues that the nuclear industry faces: scarce re-
sources of uranium on earth, storage of nuclear waste, secu-
rity concerns, etc.
References:
1. Сидоренко В. А. Безопасность использования атомной (ядерной) энергии (ядерная безопасность) // Вопросы
атомной науки и техники. Серия: Физика ядерных реакторов. 2012. № 1. с. 3–17.
2. How nuclear power can stop global warming. http://www.scientificamerican.com/article/how-nuclear-power-can-
stop-global-warming/ (accessed April 12, 2015).
3. Is nuclear power a global warming solution? http://timeforchange.org/pros-cons-nuclear-power-global-warming-
solution (accessed April 12, 2015).
4. Is nuclear power safe for humans and the environment? http://alternativeenergy.procon.org/view.answers.
php?questionID=001270 (accessed April 12, 2015).
5. Johnson T. Nuclear power safety concerns // Сиббезопасность-Спассиб. 2011. № 1. с. 172–176.
|